INSURANCE COMPANIES
American Collectors Antique Auto
800-360-2277
A Central
866-222-2242
*Offers online payment options
Adirondack Insurance Exchange
877-248-0555
Condon & Skelly Antique Auto
800-257-9496
Countryway Insurance
888-223-3649
Dryden Mutual
800-782-0154
Erie & Niagara Insurance Association
716-632-5433
Foremost
800-527-3907
Genesee Patrons
585-343-7307
Hagerty Classic
Hagerty Classic Auto: 800-747-5348
Hagerty Classic Boat: 800-762-2628
Hanover Insurance
800-628-0250
The Hartford
Hartford: 800-243-5860
Hartford Business: 800-327-3636
*Offers online payment options
J.C. Taylor Antique Auto
800-345-8290
Kemper
888-252-2799
*Offers online payment options
Liberty Mutual
800-522-7152
*Offers online payment options
Livingston Mutual
800-724-0074
Claims 24/7 – 855-725-5642
Merchants Insurance Group
claims: 800-952-5246
general: 800-462-1077
Mercury
877-533-6330
*Offers online payment options
National General Insurance
800-468-3466
*Offers online payment options
National Flood Services
800-637-3846
Main Street America/NGM Ins.
877-425-2467
*Offers online payment options
New York Central
888-234-6926
*Offers online payment options
NY State Insurance Department
518-474-6600
NYPIUA
800-522-3372
Philadelphia
800-765-9749
Progressive
800-274-4499
*Offers online payment options
Progressive Business
800-274-4499
Safeco
800-332-3226
Security Mutual
607-257-5001
Selective
Selective Business: 866-455-9969
Selective Worker’s Compensation: 800-305-0483
*Offers online payment options
State Insurance Fund
716-851-2000
Travelers
Personal: 800-252-4633
Business: 800-832-7839
*Offers online payment options
United Frontier
800-352-0908
Zurich
800-239-4559
Colvin Cleaners
716-873-2952
Green Genie Flood/Fire/Mold
716-466-6653
Rapid Dry
716-379-3939
ServiceMaster Clean
716-826-6976
ServPro
716-694-9949
Sullivan’s Cleaning & Restoration
716-699-3336